It's hard to let go, no matter how good the reason may be, or how horrible the relationship was. For people like me, us sentimental types, we hoped for the best. Even when we knew better, even when we were angry, yelling, I'm done! I'm over this! Even when things are completely and utterly broken.
I had a thought as I was driving home tonight. I was asking myself why do you care? Why does it matter? I am one of those people you can describe as a "fixer". For whatever reason, I tend to get into relationships with people who I find out are broken, and I try to "fix" them. I'm not good at it. I'm also not completely conscious of it. If you had asked me why I got into my most recent relationship, I wouldn't be able to tell you. It wasn't because I thought he was a great guy, or because I thought we were a good fit. I had grown to enjoy his company, but I wasn't sure of him in the beginning. I liked that he liked me, but lots of guys have liked me without me giving them the time of day.
Then, like I said, I thought occurred to me. He was like my mother. He wasn't like her personality-wise, looks-wise, or in any other tangible way similar to my mother at all. But he was smart, different, and seemingly without many close friends. His stories were awkwardly told, like they weren't completely true, like he wanted to seem more interesting. His jokes were generally good natured and goofy, a kind of humor that won't get you very far in the service industry. He was opinionated in a way that seemed immature and naive. He was staunchly devoted to following any and all rules at the restaurant we worked at - a good employee whose constant pointing out of things done wrong rubbed people the wrong way. Quite simply point, he wasn't cool, and he was unashamed.
My mother had a hard time making friends. I saw the good in her, but I also saw the way her naive opinions rubbed people the wrong way, how the unbending line of her thought was something that eventually signaled a mind that was broken. I have often thought about when it all started for her. What was the breaking point? What would I have done differently if I had known she would lose her mental faculties? Was there something that could have been done to prevent it, to fix her?
I have dated one other man who was obviously, painstakingly broken. The relationship was horrible, and now, seven years later, the texts I receive from him are heartbreaking. He suffered his own break with reality within the last few years. I don't think it's a coincidence. My friend Gianluca once told me about a theory that people seek out relationships that have problems similar to those they witnessed in their childhoods, and they try to fix the things that were wrong for them in the beginning. For me, these relationships were not the same, in fact they were all quite different, different types of guys, different problems. But I think some part of me recognized a brokenness, a slight similarity, and I went back in my head to that massively devastating thing that I wasn't able to keep from happening, and I said let me love you, let me fix you, let me try before it's too late. And I'm not good at it, and it doesn't work. But how do you stop yourself, when it's like you've gone back in time, back to that critical moment before everything was lost? I don't even know it's happening until it's too late, when the signs become too clear that I cannot fix this anymore.
There is real love there, in trying to fix something that is broken. I think that's what gives rise to magical thinking. Knowing, from experience, that something is wrong here and I can't ignore it, and trying to hold on to those last few moments of happiness before you finally concede that I cannot fix you.
